We are insurance for people who take insurance seriously.

We compare insurance companies so you can make the right choice.



Integrity First Insurance

Proudly serving Colorado, North Dakota and Minnesota



Insurance is confusing and time consuming.

Exploring options and finding the right insurance company on your own is not easy or quick. Many companies say price is all you should worry about. They want you to save money with a 15 minute phone call or by naming your own price. 

Without proper coverage, the risks are real.

  • If you are at-fault for an accident, you can expect lawyers to get involved. This explains why we see so many personal injury commercials.
  • Those personal injury commercials focus on big insurance companies, but what they don't tell you is that once your insurance company pays out your policy limits, your personal finances and even future income can be targeted.
  • Some lawyers have recovered billions of dollars for their clients over the years, but not all of that money came from insurance companies. A lot of that came from someone just like you.

Are you prepared to risk your finances?

Additional coverage is often very affordable through an Umbrella Policy.


Let us guide you through your options.

Integrity First Insurance

Our process is simple:

Request Quote | Integrity First Insurance

We'll compare over 20 companies.

Review Options | Integrity First Insurance

Review Options

An Integrity First advisor will  guide you through your quote.
Be The Hero | Integrity First Insurance

Be The Hero

What's more heroic than properly protecting your family or business?
We're Here To Help | Integrity First Insurance

We're Here To Help

You're the boss. We work for you, not the insurance company. 
Years in business
Active policies
5-star Google reviews
Combined years of experience

"I appreciated that you answered all my questions and took your time to help me understand the different insurance policies I was considering. Thank you for everything."


Ann via Google

"Outstanding experience with Rick at Integrity First. He was proactive, patient, and a great communicator. I understood every step of the process, and he was always available when I had a question. Highly recommended."


Julie via Google

"When I needed to add my motor home to my policy, Vanida worked quickly to get me covered. She always works hard to meet my needs in a timely manner."


Robin via Google

"Heather did a wonderful job fulfilling our insurance needs in CO and was very responsive with all questions and details."


Karen via Google

Our legacy will go beyond the insurance industry through the charities we support and the animals we passionately help.

We Love Shelter Pets!

Integrity First Insurance

Your referral supports local animal shelters.

Shelter Pets Program

Your referrals mean the world to us.

Our agency has a strong passion for dogs, and in an effort to make a difference beyond the insurance industry, we are donating both time and money to local animal shelters.

Our program is simple: For every referral you send to our agency, we’ll donate $15.00 to the Humane Society of the South Platte Valley on your behalf.

How to send a referral:

  1. Please have your referral call us at (303) 597-1667 for a quote and indicate you referred them.
  2. Or, they can fill out our Request Quote form and indicate you referred them. 
  3. We will discuss their insurance needs and provide a quote. They do not need to purchase a policy for a donation to be made.
  4. Once the quote has been given, we will make a $15.00 donation to the Humane Society of the South Platte Valley.
  5. You will receive notification that a donation has been made on your behalf. 
Humane Society of the South Platte Valley | Integrity First Insurance

Humane Society of the South Platte Valley